Photo: Neilson Barnard/Getty; Randy Shropshire/Getty

Danielle Fishel and Ben Savage

Danielle Fishelmay have disappointed die-hardBoy Meets Worldfans at 90s Con when she revealed that a real-life romance with costarBen Savagenever happened.

When asked on Saturday if she ever had a relationship with her costar from the popular coming-of-age 1990s sitcom, Fishel said, “No, we never dated.”

However, after a couple of years of playing childhood sweethearts Cory Matthews and Topanga Lawrence, Fishel admitted that she and Savage did try to give it a shot.

“There was literally I think one moment where Ben and I looked at each other after we had been working together for like two years and were like, ‘Are there feelings there?'” she explained. “And then we went out to dinner, and we were like, ‘No!’ "

Though there was no romantic spark between Fishel, 40, and Savage, 41, the actors were still extremely close off set. Fishel even asked Savage to a school dance — and the night went down in true teenage sitcom fashion.

ABC Photo Archives/Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty

Ben Savage and Danielle Fishel Boy Meets World

“We had what they used to call the vice-versa dance at our school. They called it that because — in a very misogynistic way — the girls were supposed to ask the boys,” she shared. “So I was supposed to ask somebody, and I asked Ben if he would go with me, and he did. And, actually, this is one of my favorite stories.”

Fishel noted that Savage forgot to take his wallet and that she didn’t have any money on her either, so when their night ended with a bite at Denny’s, they almost got stuck washing dishes.

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

“We went to Denny’s and ate food, and they brought us the bill, and we were like, ‘Oh, we don’t have any money!’ I had to keep my purse there as collateral, and we drove to my parents’ house, got money, and then drove back to Denny’s and were like, ‘Thank you so much!’ "

When asked about the dance with Savage, Fishel clarified that it wasn’t prom; she had another famous date for that monumental teenage moment. “I actually broughtLance Bassto my prom!” she said.

Emily Assiran/Contour/Getty

90’s Con Portrait Studio

In February of last year, Fishel and Savage talked to PEOPLE about some ofthe most romantic momentsbetween Cory and Topanga, the beloved 1990s couple who fell in love in their early adolescence, dated their way through college, and eventually married in the show’s final season.

“One of my favorite romantic moments is at the end ofthe ‘Starry Night’ episode,” Fishel said, referring to Cory and Topanga’s brief breakup. “When Cory says to Shawn, ‘What an interesting feeling it is,’ and Shawn says, ‘To know that it’s over?’ And Cory says, ‘No, to be the only person who knows that it’s not.’ "

source: people.com