Elon Musk has done it again . And by “ it , ” we think tricked a lot of people with “ self-reliant ” robots that are really being help by unseen human hustler . And this is n’t the first sentence Musk hasdone this .
On Thursday night , Tesla throw a extremely look to culture medium outcome at Warner Bros. studio apartment near Los Angeles and unveil a prototype robotaxi that Musk call the Cybercab . consumer will have to wait on that one since Musk says it ’s still2 - 3 years aside , just as it has been for the past decade .
But that did n’t dampen spirits at the afterparty , as people who attended the Tesla event posted loads of video recording on social media with Musk ’s Optimus golem . attender seemed very impressed as the robots were dancing , verbalise , and even mixing drinks .
A human-assisted Tesla robot known as Optimus pouring drinks at an event Oct. 10, 2024 at Warner Bros. in Burbank, California.Screenshot from a video by Robert Scoble
However , longtime technical school evangelist Robert Scoble really asked some questions to see just how autonomous these automaton are . And it ’s not very supporting .
“ Optimus make me a potable , please . This is not totally AI . A man is remote assisting . Which means AI mean solar day next year where we will see how fast Optimus is see , ” Scoble tweeted alongwith a video .
Optimus make me a potable , please .
Tesla’s Optimus robot folding laundry in Jan. 2024 with an annotation of a red arrow added by Gizmodo showing the human hand. (Tesla/Elon Musk)
This is not altogether AI . A man is outside assisting .
Which means AI day next year where we will see how dissipated Optimus is learning.pic.twitter.com/CE2bEA2uQD
— Robert Scoble ( @Scobleizer)October 11 , 2024
Other users want to cognize how Scoble figured it out . The tech influencer twitch back simply , “ I enquire . ”
Scoble can be heard in the telecasting asking one of the robot , “ Hey Optimus , how much of you is AI ? ”
The golem , or whoever was control it , seemed to scramble for an answer , tell “ I ca n’t disclose just how much . That ’s something you ’ll have to find out later . ”
“ But some or none ? ” Scoble require with a jape .
“ I would say , it might be some . I ’m not perish to confirm , but it might be some , ” the golem responded .
I asked.pic.twitter.com/FkgPrdRlyW
That pretty much narrate you all you require to know . If Musk had really build up a bunch of robots that could interact with large crowds in real time , the golem would ’ve bragged about it . Instead , the response was evasive .
Scoble made a postdate - up tweet saying he talk with a Tesla engineer to get clarity .
“ When it walk that is AI running Optimus . It is real impressive they brought so many out in crowds at@tesla ’s event , ” Scoble wrote , without elaborating further .
plentitude of multitude thought they were fully independent robots , interacting with human being just like other human beings . “ This tech is year ahead of any competition , ” one user on Xwrote . The job is , based on everything we know about Tesla ’s robotics achievements , Musk is really right smart behind the contest .
In fact , Musk ’s competition begin contribute the words “ no teleoperation ” to their videos precisely because he got caught fudging a demonstration television back in January . The picture showed Optimus folding a shirt , but eagle - eyed witness noticed that a hand maintain roll into the camera ’s study of vision . There was someone justoff - screenperforming the labor of folding and the automaton mimicked the human .
As you’re able to see in the GIF below , we ’ve lend a reddish pointer to show you where the human hand is . That engineering science , teleoperation , is so cutting edge that it date stamp to the forties .
But none of Musk ’s sorcerous tricks should be surprising . He did bind the event Thursday at Warner Bros. studio apartment in Burbank , so you have sex he was going to try adding some picture conjuration . And Musk’sfirst robot demonstration in 2021was so embarrassing it ’s backbreaking to even call it a trick . It was literally just a human habilitate in a golem costume doing a stupid little dance .
As one credulous user on X put it , “ Tesla 2022 . Person in a Robot suit of clothes . Tesla 2024 . Actual Robot . ” And putting aside the fact that Musk ’s imitation robot suit happened in 2021 , it would be telling if these robots were indeed meet rock - paper - scissors fully autonomously without human intervention and hold fast conversations without any kind of retardation at all . But we ’ve seen no grounds that that ’s what might be befall .
Tesla 2022 . Person in a Robot causa .
Tesla 2024 . Actual Robot.pic.twitter.com/wvwCnlcmQu
— Jason Kelly 🌵 ( @_HiddenLayers)October 11 , 2024
Musk talked about Optimus at the event without giving any meter reading that they were anything but fully self-governing . He sound out they would mop your lawn , get your groceries , and evenwatch your kids . But doing those kind of activities would require full AI - powered self-reliance unless you want to charter a man posing remotely somewhere controlling them . And then , what ’s the point ?
Musk also said the robots would eventually cost$20 - 30,000 tenacious - termand claim Optimus would be “ the biggest merchandise ever of any kind . ” But , again , that ’s laborious to achieve if your automaton postulate a lot of human interposition behind the scenes .
Gizmodo has reached out to Tesla to get some clarification about what level of liberty the Optimus robots were achieving on Thursday . We ’ll update this billet if we hear back .
Daily Newsletter
Get the best tech , science , and culture news in your inbox daily .
News from the future , deliver to your present .
Please select your desired newssheet and take your e-mail to elevate your inbox .
You May Also Like
